|
Todd Haynes takes a cheeky look at glam rock by Shawn Levy Velvet Goldmine, the latest film from itchy writer-director Todd Haynes (Poison, Safe), is nothing if not ambitious. The film is, to list some of its various parts, a history of British glam rock, an indictment of the conservative economics of the American 80's, a paean to sexual freedom, a shaggy-dog mystery story, and a speculative fiction that surmises, among other things, that Oscar Wilde was a space alien. Naturally, a scattershot approach like this will tend to produce mixed results, and Haynes doesn't make things very clear with the films multiple time-shifts and unreliable narrators. In short, for all its laudable reach, for its handful of impressive performances, and for its delightful and delighted play with fashion, makeup and decor, Velvet Goldmine is a lot like the glam rock that it celebrates: garish and shrill and outr, if undeniably sexy and cheeky. The film tells the story of Brian Slade (Jonathan Rhys-Meyers), a character modeled on the likes of David Bowie, Brian Eno, Marc Bolan and Jim Morrison, a god of glam rock who rejected his fans in the mid-70's by faking his own death and then, when caught in the fraud, disappearing altogether. A decade later, Arthur Stuart (Christian Bale), a young Briton working at a New York newspaper, is assigned to find out whatever happened to Slade. In a string of sequences cribbed (almost, in some cases, exactly) from Citizen Kane, Arthur, who went through his own youthful fascination with the fashions and sexual ambiguities of glam rock, tracks down some of Slade's old circle to try to find the reclusive star. Despite all the good filmmaking here, Velvet Goldmine finally falls from its own dispersed energy. The film juggles the memories of Slade's ex-wife (Toni Collette) and his first manager (Michael Feast) along with Arthur's own personal recollections, some set pieces (rock concerts and assorted happenings) and some pure fantasy (one scene, alluding to Haynes underground classic, The Karen Carpenter Story, is acted out by dolls). Slade is the object of the quest, but the soul of the film rests in the persona of Curt Wild (Ewan McGregor), the Iggy Pop-ish dervish whose music and way of life lack Slade's craft, perhaps, but are also free of his guile and self-serving calculation. Wild and Slade were once partners -- lovers, even -- and the split between them helped drive Slade into ducking his public. (Arthur, too, has had a close-up brush with Slade, but the addled old rocker can't recall it when Arthur finally tracks him down.) All of this is played in a kind of sensual swoon by Haynes and company. A good third of the film is given over to musical numbers, some exceedingly elaborate. These are occasionally thrilling, conveying the giddy excitement that drove Haynes into the project, but they don't exactly tie things together. The acting, too, is infectious, although not quite uniformly. McGregor conveys Wild's rage viscerally (and, coincidentally, is a spitting image, during a scene in a recording studio, of Kurt Cobain). Collette shows more worldly depth than ever before, playing sexy and bitter and worldly wise with great skill. Rhys-Meyers, on the other hand, is mostly petulant -- just try to suppress the urge to smack him -- and comedian Eddie Izzard plays Slade's gaudy manager a la Keith Moon (heaven help us). Despite all the good filmmaking here, Velvet Goldmine finally falls from its own dispersed energy. Its so busy trying to drink in a lost era that it never really makes the case that the eras passing is worth mourning.
|